A person standing in a beam of golden light cast through a doorway against a dark blue wall.
Charitable Giving

What I Learned About True Return: Rethinking ROI Through the Lens of Generosity

As a former stock analyst, I have always appreciated the clarity of financial ratios. Numbers provide context. They help investors compare opportunities, evaluate performance, and decide how to allocate resources. Few financial ratios are as familiar as ROI, or return on investment.

But I was recently challenged to think about ROI in a completely different way.

At a recent lunch and learn event, Andrew Allen, president and CEO of YSS, spoke about the value of applying business financial metrics to opportunities for charitable giving. (More information about Andrew and YSS can be found on page 12).

Traditionally, ROI measures profitability: profit divided by the cost of an investment. If you invest $100 and earn a $50 profit, your ROI is 50 percent. Investors use the metric to evaluate success and compare alternatives.

But what happens when the investment is not financial?

We support charities and other nonprofits by making “donations” and “gifts.” If you’re like me, you haven’t thought of these as “investments.” Yet we are always making deliberate decisions to invest in a mission, a cause, or a better future.

What if We Measured ROI, Not by Financial Return, but by Impact?

For those of us with finance-oriented minds, that naturally raises a question: How do you measure impact?

Impact is not always visible on a spreadsheet. It may emerge over years through changed lives, new opportunities, restored hope, or stronger communities. It’s a return that may never appear in a quarterly report. But its value can be profound.

Andrew illustrated this through his own story. Years ago, he benefited from the very organization he now leads. The donors who supported YSS could never have predicted their contributions would help shape the career of a future CEO. Yet their investment created a ripple effect far beyond what they could see at the time.

Andrew’s story prompted me to reflect on how generosity has impacted my own family.

Several years ago, while my daughter was considering a legal career, an alumnus offered her a summer internship at his Houston law firm. He also provided lodging and a salary, removing financial barriers that often accompany early career opportunities. Naturally, I wanted to learn more about him.

I discovered that he is among the nation’s most accomplished litigators. And while I was impressed with his success, I was even more impressed by how he chose to use it.

Rather than focusing on personal luxuries, he invests in opportunities for others. He champions projects and causes designed to educate and inspire future generations, long after he’s gone – like the theological library he founded in Houston or the seminary he built in partnership with Baylor University.

That is impact.

My daughter is only one of the many people whose lives have been touched by his generosity. Countless others will benefit from opportunities created through the profound impact of his generosity.

The more I reflect on his story, the more compelling Andrew’s expanded definition of ROI becomes.

In finance, returns can be measured in dollars and percentages. In generosity, returns can be measured in transformed lives, strengthened communities, and opportunities created for others.

The exciting thing about charitable investments is that their long-term impact may never be fully known. A scholarship recipient becomes a teacher. A struggling family finds stability. A young intern discovers a calling. A nonprofit beneficiary becomes its leader. Outcomes extend far beyond the original gift.

Some of the most meaningful investments we can make are the ones whose returns cannot be fully calculated. But where impact can be measured in generations.

Gretchen Muller is Director of Communications for Foster Group, where she engages with clients across multiple platforms to share thoughtful and practical financial perspectives.

Keep Reading

Gretchen Muller Ashlee Vieregger
Charitable Giving

Financial Perspectives: How to Give with a Plan

Hosted by : Gretchen Muller & Ashlee Vieregger

11/16/26

Cheesecake
Financial Planning Charitable Giving

Too Many Choices: Turning Charitable Intent Into a Meaningful Charitable Giving Strategy

Ashlee Vieregger

Ashlee Vieregger, JD, CFP, CTFA, AEP, TPCP

11/10/26

Charitable Giving

Charitable Giving: Ending the Year with Purpose

Gretchen Muller

Gretchen Muller, MBA

12/17/25

Charitable Giving

Have You Considered the Realtime Gratification of Warm Giving?

Matt Abels

Matt Abels, CFP, CPWA

12/16/25

Gretchen Muller Ashlee Vieregger
Charitable Giving

Financial Perspectives: Year-End Giving Checklist

Hosted by : Gretchen Muller & Ashlee Vieregger

12/15/25

Charitable Giving

Chart of the Month – December 2025

Garrett Jackson

Garrett Jackson, CFA, FPQP

12/11/25

Charitable Giving Families

The Five Generosity Languages

Ashlee Vieregger

Ashlee Vieregger, JD, CFP, CTFA, AEP, TPCP

12/09/25

Charitable Giving Lifestyle

What I Learned About Listening to My Heart

Jerry Foster

Jerry Foster

12/02/25

Charitable Giving

Generosity in Action with Greater Des Moines Habitat for Humanity

Kent Kramer

Kent Kramer

12/02/25

Financial Planning Charitable Giving

Smart Tax Moves for Year–End 2025: How to Make the Most of Your Brackets

Ethan Gascho

Ethan Gascho, CFP

10/21/25

Marcus Iwig Kent Kramer
Financial Planning Charitable Giving

Financial Perspectives: OBBBA Explained – What the 2025 Tax Bill Might Mean for You

Hosted by : Marcus Iwig & Kent Kramer

09/15/25

Ashlee Vieregger Kent Kramer
Financial Planning Charitable Giving

Financial Perspectives: 2025 Estate Planning – Tax Changes, Documents, and What to Know

Hosted by : Ashlee Vieregger & Kent Kramer

07/14/25

PLEASE SEE IMPORTANT DISCLOSURE INFORMATION at www.fostergrp.com/disclosures. A copy of our written disclosure Brochure as set forth on Part 2A of Form ADV is available at www.adviserinfo.sec.gov.

Let’s talk.

Let’s talk.

Contact us – without obligation – whenever you have a financial question, idea, or need a second opinion. And discover how having your financial life Truly Cared For can help you feel more confident and in control. You can select your preference to start a conversation.

Prefer to call us? 515-226-9000

Prefer to call us? 515-226-9000

By providing a telephone number and submitting the form, you are consenting to be contacted by SMS text message from Foster Group. Message frequency may vary. Message and data rates may apply. Reply STOP to opt out of further messaging. Reply HELP for more information. See our Privacy Policy.